I have this long-time friend. Last week, she moved out of her house, leaving her husband of 25 plus years, and two grown children, plus a daughter that’s still in high school.
“Alice” (not her real name) is so happy — relieved — about this situation. Her high school-er ever told her, “I’m glad you left. I haven’t seen you this happy ever, and I don’t want you to go back to dad.” I’m a little dazed and confused, because in my “understanding,” the only reason she was unhappy in her relationship was that she was unfulfilled.
Alice came from a traditional church background. Born and raised in a evangelical community, she met “John” (again, not his real name) soon after he was “born again,” and they were married and became a part of their church. Work, children, and life followed, and while things weren’t perfect, they were “normal,” by any definition of the word.
A few years ago, Alice’s father died suddenly. This sent her for a tailspin, one from which I don’t think she’s still fully recovered. I think this event opened her eyes, a bit. Her dad had kind of lived a “double life,” presenting one image at church, and another at home. He wasn’t abusive or anything … he was just very, very selfish and stubborn and unloving. Funny thing, Alice is a lot like him (and will tell you that herself).
I’ve kind of lost touch with Alice, because we’ve moved and she went on to work full-time. Her kids have struggled with various things, but it seems like the family is on an “upswing” of sorts. Then, the news that she decided to walk out on John the week of Thanksgiving …
I know we never “know” anyone’s story from the outside. And please don’t think I’m judging Alice at all, because I’m not. But this whole experience has me shaken a bit.
Alice said her one daughter is struggling, and I know why. We’re taught that marriage is “for better, or worse.” We’re taught that marriage has little to do with us, and more about how we serve and love another. We’re told that staying with the person we marry is the way to keep society running smoothly — for the kids, etc. And, while there are many cases where divorce is “acceptable” (cases of infidelity or abuse, etc.), in my sheltered definition, this isn’t one of those times.
What brings a person to this line, then pushes them over it? How can someone walk away from a half a lifetime with someone, simply because they don’t feel appreciated, or fulfilled, or “financially stable” (which means she doesn’t have as much money as she wants — they have a house, three cars, remodeled kitchen, etc.).
Part of me is angry. I also know John, and think he’s a great guy. Yeah, he’s very passive. But that’s given Alice all kinds of freedom. In fact, she has blamed him for many things that she herself has let happen. And he’s always errored on the side of peace, you know? I’ve also seen her undermind him when he’s tried to make decisions that he thought would help the family. So, he’s resorted to passive-aggressive behaviors that have hurt her. But in this relationship, she’s the one who’s taken very little personal responsibility. In fact, she’ll tell you she stopped trying, because he didn’t “do” what he should have known to do. And I understand that … my husband and I have similar conversations. But to walk away from the man because he can’t read my mind? OK, I have a lot of guy friends. There are only a few who I would call perceptive, and even they struggle with their own wives! It just “is what it is,” you know?
I know divorce is a reality of life. But I also know when the proverbial “shit” hits the fan, I want to fight for the investment I’ve made in my marriage, not walk away. (OK, we all think about it at times, but to actually DO it?). This event has been a long time in coming in Alice’s life. It shouldn’t have been a shock to me — she’s been very open in discussing the whole thing.
But it has shaken me to the core, just the same.